Each month in 2021, I’ll be posting a ranked list of some of my favorite director’s films. Be sure to check back in February for the latest entry.
To kick off my Ranked series, we are going to take a look at the career of Maya Rudolph’s husband: Paul Thomas Anderson. A man who, despite his eight Oscar-losses (R.I.P.), is one of the most consistently exceptional filmmakers in modern American cinema. From a horny mystery to a horny Scientology allegory to a movie about literal porn, the man can truly do it all.
8. Inherent Vice

I’ll get this out of the way early; to date, Paul Thomas Anderson has never made a bad movie. In fact, I don’t think he has ever made a movie that isn’t great. However, with Inherent Vice, I’m always left with a lingering sense of frustration. It has some stellar direction, and it gets another killer performance out of Joaquin Phoenix alongside a star-making turn from Katherine Waterson, yet it always just feels like something is missing.
Maybe I need to get wasted out of my mind the next time I watch it. Maybe I need to give Pynchon’s novel a shot. But for now, all I can say is that it takes the prize as my least favorite of Anderson’s works.
Martin Short is fucking hilarious, though.
7. Hard Eight

An incredible debut that, more importantly, is a powerful showcase for the leading-man talents of Phillip Baker Hall and John C. Reilly. Two actors who, even in some of the later works of Anderson, are often relegated to supporting films. That’s not to say that they don’t absolutely nail their supporting roles (I’m looking at you in particular, Boogie Nights), but god damn if it doesn’t rule to see the two of them get to lead.
As a relatively unknown entry in an otherwise widely-known and beloved filmography, Hard Eight never seems to get the praise that it deserves. It’s a playful, riveting drama, one worthy of just as much praise as any other of Anderson’s works.
6. The Master

An actor’s movie, through and through. Somehow you get Joaquin Phoenix, Philip Seymour Hoffman AND Amy Adams, all of whose careers are full of dozens of rich and wonderful performances, giving near career-best work in The Master. It is endlessly quotable (“If you already know the answers to your questions, then why ask PIG FUCK?”) and, just like several other entries on this list, isn’t bogged down by its lengthy runtime, but rather enriched by it.
Also, while Phantom Thread and Boogie Nights are certainly in the running, this must be Anderson’s most horny movie. I mean, in the first five minutes of The Master, Phoenix literally has sex with a sand sculpture. I don’t know how you can get any hornier than that.
5. Magnolia

Raining frogs. Tom Cruise as a horned-up motivational speaker/predator. A children’s gameshow host named fucking Jimmy Gator. A runtime of just over three (!) hours.
Magnolia is an epic in every sense of the word. It is operatic and bloated and melodramatic, and it all comes together to equal something that I’ve never quite seen before. It certainly isn’t for everyone, but if this hits for you, it truly is a special film.
4. There Will Be Blood

One of those films that, if directed by most other filmmakers, would be the absolute pinnacle of their career. There Will Be Blood is a testament to not just Anderson’s talents, but to those of his film’s star, Daniel Day-Lewis. In a career full of critical acclaim (only actor to win Best Actor in a Leading Role three times) and widespread commercial love, this may be the finest performance in his entire career. It is most immediately comparable to that of Orson Welles’ in Citizen Kane, one that spans time and characterization in a way that few other performances are able to capture.
And also, to answer the age old questions: should this have beaten No Country For Old Men for Best Picture? My answer: Maybe!
3. Boogie Nights

I’m a star, I’m a star. I’m a big, bright shining star.
Just pump me full of whatever they were filling Marky Mark with in this. Anytime you watch one of his more recent performances, it’s like watching someone’s roided-up gym teacher trying to scold you for making fun of his foster kids or something. But Boogie Nights Wahlberg? Yeah, that’s the good stuff.
2. Phantom Thread

While his performance in There Will Be Blood may be the best performance of Daniel Day-Lewis’ career, there is no performance of his that I cherish more than his in Phantom Thread. However, despite it containing my favorite performance from one of the world’s greatest actors, living or dead, it isn’t even my favorite performance of the film. That honor belongs to the unfathomably brilliant performance of Vicky Krieps.
Of the best decade or so, there has never been a performance that caught me off guard as much of that of Krieps. With Phantom Thread being yet another Day-Lewis/Anderson collaboration, those were the two I came in anticipating to be wowed by. Yet to watch Krieps, an actress who I previously had never even heard of, give such a deeply nuanced and commanding performance absolutely floored me. I instantly fell for her, much like I did with Kirsten Dunst in The Virgin Suicides or Julie Delpy in Before Sunrise. It is a magnetic performance within a magnetic film, one that I often find myself thirsting to watch yet again.
1. Punch-Drunk Love

When Punch-Drunk Love is brought up, it is often to prove that Adam Sandler is a “capable” actor, alongside his wonderful performances in Uncut Gems and The Meyerowitz Stories. This conversation is painfully reductive, as it imagines Sandler as a hapless actor who, once every decade or two, pulls off some astounding feat and delivers a nuanced performance. Instead, the conversation should not be about whether or not Sandler is a good actor, but rather if he is one of our best actors.
Punch-Drunk Love is probably the closest we will get to another Sirk film. It’s colors are as vibrant as its romance between Sandler and the never better Emily Watson, and their first kiss is as powerful as that of Wyman and Hudson in Sirk’s crowning masterpiece, All That Heaven Allows. And it’s all centered by Sandler’s performance, one that is truly remarkable in not just its range, but it’s pure depth of emotion. It is a performance that most actors can only dream of, a big old middle finger to the countless moviegoers who think of Sandler for his Jack and Jill-esque roles. I’ll admit, I was once a Sandler-skeptic, but damn am I reformed.
Punch-Drunk Love is not just one of Anderson’s best films; it is one of the best American films ever made. It is ridiculously watchable and painfully relatable, a stunning showcase of the vast narrative, visual and directorial talents of Anderson. Let’s hope he has plenty left in the tank.

































